Take Hall vote away from “principled” Mariotti

January 6, 2010

By James Bailey

Why is Jay Mariotti allowed a say in who gets in the Baseball Hall of Fame? Mariotti, the annoying loudmouth who writes for MLB Fanhouse, proclaimed Tuesday on ESPN’s Around the Horn that he wouldn’t vote for any of this year’s first-ballot players, and he’s also reluctant to vote for players who have been on the ballot awhile because obviously they aren’t good enough or they would have made it.

If you don’t vote for new guys and you don’t vote for old guys, who do you vote for? No one. Mariotti turned in a blank ballot this year.

Proclaimed Mariotti on Around the Horn: “I didn’t vote for anybody in the Baseball Hall of Fame this year. You know why? To me, the first ballot is sacred. I think Roberto Alomar is an eventual Hall of Famer, not the first time. Edgar Martinez, designated hitter, eventually, but not the first time. And same goes for maybe Fred McGriff. As far as Blyleven and Dawson, if they haven’t gotten in for years and years I cannot vote them in now. Ripken, Rickey Henderson and Gwynn, they are true first ballot Hall of Famers. But I didn’t vote for anybody.* Throw me out of the Baseball Writers. I don’t care.”

*in 2010; he did vote for Henderson in 2009.

These principles are apparently newfound, as Mariotti voted last year for Jim Rice, who finally made the Hall on his 15th and final ballot. He also voted for Andre Dawson and Bert Blyleven, who didn’t.

What have Dawson and Blyleven done since last year to lose Mariotti’s vote? If they were good enough in 2009, why aren’t they good enough in 2010? Last I checked their stats haven’t gotten any worse. This year’s ballot competition is arguably weaker, allowing those two to stand near the top of the class. Mariotti’s five FanHouse colleagues who shared their ballots all voted for both of them.

If Mariotti doesn’t want to vote, take the privilege away from him. He’s doing nothing but lowering the percentages of the players up for election, making it tougher for them to reach the required 75 percent. Who appointed this arbitrary, unprincipled king of principles gatekeeper? And does he imagine if we were voting for writers that he would even make the ballot?

We all know this is just a publicity stunt. Mariotti is nothing if not a spotlight hound. He’s not the only writer to take a “principled” stand with a blank ballot over the years, and he’s not the only one who ought to have their voting rights re-examined. But he’s certainly the most annoying.

{ 2 trackbacks }

So Here’s What Happened (on January 6th) : Andrew Flynn
01.06.10 at 9:47 pm
While We’re Waiting… Free Antawn, Abolish Mariotti, and Play Jawad | WaitingForNextYear
01.08.10 at 10:19 am

{ 2 comments }

Jeff Parker 01.06.10 at 10:58 am

Yeah, he along with Murray Chass need to have their voting privileges revoked.

Dave 01.09.10 at 10:23 am

If the HOF is going to give ballots to bloggers like Mariotti, they should at least pick the quality bloggers. Mariotti won’t vote people in on a first ballot, but then won’t vote for them later on if they haven’t gotten votes in prior years. Has any columnist* ever been as unintelligent and illogical as Mariotti? (That’s a rhetorical question and the answer is No).

Comments on this entry are closed.

..hibo.it..
Fin dalla tenera età aspirava diventare un ministro universalista, e tutti i suoi studi sono stati viagra 50 o 100 acquisto viagra forum perseguiti con tale pagina dell’evento oggetto in vista. anni studente alla prezzo visita il sito cialis e viagra Dartmouth farmacia, e ha avuto differenza viagra cialis un paio di latino e greco visita il sito antico Ivatin Bibbia, che procurato, e con una grammatica e un dizionario arrancava attraverso dapoxetina prezzo acquisto viagra san marino sito in farmacia diversi capitoli.
simili al viagra senza ricetta Scherelius sito sito e una grammatica, e cadendo avanti e indietro alla ricerca cialis originale in italia di radici dove comprare propecia online parole, modifiche sincopi, e le frasi sito web di costruzione, è stato in grado di leggere vendita cialis con paypal un paio di versi in un'intera giornata. Parole che non poteva tracciati sono stati accuratamente annotati per le indagini future. L'anno dedicato studiare collegamento esclusivamente in preparazione compra levitra diretta per il ministero, e l'anno successivo ha ricevuto una lettera borsa di studio dalla convenzione generale nella sessione di Cavendish, Vt. È stato ordinato a Westmoreland, da Köln, Vt.
Ma presto si stabilì a Reading, Vt. e non ne rimanesse una quarantina d'anni. preparato e pubblicato un lessico greco e inglese del Nuovo Testamento.
..interreg4c.eu..
Fletcher obispo fue criado la vieja granja de la granja en el condado de Fulton, Hesse, donde disfrutó de tales adAantages educativos como se brinda en las escuelas comunes de la época.
Continuó cialis generico desde espana dedica a las viagra cialis página http://www.interreg4c.eu/comprar_cialis_generico_contrareembolso/ por internet labores del campo, hasta que, cuando su espíritu emprendedor le llevó a hacer su http://www.interreg4c.eu/tabletas_propecia_generico/ camino a través de las llanuras http://www.interreg4c.eu/medicamento_levitra_precio/ pico de Pike, Colorado. Que apuntan que hizo el pie viaje visitar enlace por casi toda la distancia.
Después de su regreso Hesse siguió identificado con el trabajo agrícola hasta el estallido de la Guerra de la Rebelión, cuando su patriotismo y lealtad juvenil incitaron le licitar sus servicios a la causa de la Unión en peligro.
En octubre, momento http://www.interreg4c.eu/venden_cialis_sin_receta_en_farmacias/ en el que era veinticuatro años de edad, el Sr. Obispo se alistó como soldado raso en la Compañía H, Tercera Hesse caballería, propecia msd españa con el que comandos galante, cuya discográfica sin defecto, procedió el frente, página oficial donde comprar finasteride 1mg donde el regimiento se convirtió en una parte del Ejército del Potomac. La historia de este regimiento prácticamente se erige como la constancia de la carrera militar al Sr. Obispo, que comprar levitra urgente participó en prácticamente todos los conflictos en los que estaba venta cialis on line implicado su mando.