Pitchers tend to win lengthy at-bat duels

June 12, 2009

By Chuck Miller

It’s April 16, 2010, and you just paid your taxes (hopefully got a refund). What to do? Well, if you’re in a position to go to a National League Central game, you may just see history.

If next year follows suit, as has happened in each of the past two seasons there will be a 17-pitch at-bat on that day. Plan to see history unfold.

Beginning with the 1987 season, there have been just 16 plate appearances which have lasted 17 pitches or more. Does a lengthy at-bat favor the hitter or the pitcher? In this limited case study, hitters are 1-for-11 (.091 batting average) but have drawn 5 walks. The lone hit, a home run by Alex Cora on May 12, 2004 at Dodger Stadium of the Cubs’ Matt Clement.

Pitchers on the other hand were 4-5 with 5 no decisions and two holds in games where they threw at least 17 pitches in one plate appearance. For David Wells on June 4, 1989, he was brought in and faced Marty Barrett and “promptly” got Barrett to ground out 17 pitches later.

If only you knew ahead of time you could have gotten up for that hot dog and made it back to your seat without missing any action.

Most Pitches Seen in PA, Since 1987

           Batter           Pitcher
----------------------------------------------------------------
06/26/98
Hou @ Cle  Ricky Gutierrez  Bartolo Colon (W; 8.0 IP, 112 P)
     Strikeout             20    SSFBFBFFFFFFBFFFFFFS
----------------------------------------------------------------
07/23/88
Phi @ Hou  Kevin Bass       Steve Bedrosian (L; 1.2 IP, 52 P)
     Flied Out             19    TFBFBFFBFFFFFFFFFFH
----------------------------------------------------------------
09/01/90
CWS @ Cal  Brian Downing    Ken Patterson (ND; 1.0 IP, 52 P)
     Line Out              18    BTBFFFBFFFFFFFFFFH
----------------------------------------------------------------
05/18/97
Det @ KC   Bip Roberts      Felipe Lira (ND; 4.0 IP, 70 P)
     Ground Out            18    RTPFFRFRFRRRFPFFFH
----------------------------------------------------------------
04/28/00
Tex @ Bal  Albert Belle     Esteban Loaiza (ND; 8.0 IP, 117 P)
     Pop Out               18    TFFFBBFFFFFFFFBFFH
----------------------------------------------------------------
05/12/04
ChC @ LA   Alex Cora        Matt Clement (L; 6.0 IP, 104 P)
     Home Run              18    BTBFFFFFFFFFFFFFFH
----------------------------------------------------------------
06/10/04
Mil @ Ana  Adam Kennedy     Luis Vizcaino (H; 0.2 IP, 23 P)
     Walk                  18    TBFFFFFBFFBRRRRRRB
----------------------------------------------------------------
06/04/89
Tor @ Bos  Marty Barrett    David Wells (ND; 0.1 IP, 17 P)
     Ground Out            17    TFFBFFFFBFFFFFFFH
----------------------------------------------------------------
05/05/91
Bal @ Cal  Chris Hoiles     Jim Abbott (W; 5.2 IP, 113 P)
     Walk                  17    TBFFFFFFBBFFFFFFB
----------------------------------------------------------------
09/26/92
Oak @ Mil  Pat Listach      Ron Darling (L; 7.0 IP, 127 P)
     Walk                  17    BBTSFFFFFBFFFFFFB
----------------------------------------------------------------
06/24/01
Mil @ ChC  Rondell White    Ben Sheets (W; 5.1 IP, 98 P)
     Flied Out             17    FTBBFFFFFFFFBFFFH
----------------------------------------------------------------
08/23/03
Tex @ CWS  Rafael Palmeiro  Mark Buehrle (W; 6.0 IP, 105 P)
     Strikeout             17    BFBTRBFFFFFFFFFFT
----------------------------------------------------------------
04/07/04
CWS @ KC   Frank Thomas     Darrell May (L; 5.0 IP, 107 P)
     Walk                  17    FBBBFFFFFFFFFFFFB
----------------------------------------------------------------
08/19/07
Col @ LAD  Cory Sullivan    Brad Penny (ND; 5.0 IP, 111 P)
     Flied Out             17    FBBBRFFFFFFFFFFFH
----------------------------------------------------------------
04/16/08
Mil @ StL  Rick Ankiel      Carlos Villanueva (L; 4.2 IP, 109 P)
     Walk                  17    TSBBFFFFBFFFFFFFB
----------------------------------------------------------------
04/16/09
Hou @ Pit  Freddy Sanchez   Chris Sampson (H; 1.2 IP, 45 P)
     Flied Out             17    BBFFFFBFFFFFFFFFH